Who haunts the Casablanca Inn
Reported as stories, with where each one comes from. Most reported: The Lady with the Lantern.
The Lady with the Lantern
The story goes that she waved a lantern from the roof to warn rum-runners when federal agents were in town. Boaters and passers-by report a light on the roof on dark nights.
The presence inside
Guests and staff report footsteps in empty halls, a misty figure, a touch on the shoulder, a sudden scent of oranges and the sound of children playing.
Margaret Hantelman
One tour company says she died in room 8 and is seen in 1910s dress rearranging lobby flowers. Haunted Rooms found no record confirming this.
The Spanish doctor
Ghost City Tours says guests in rooms 10 and 12 report a tall figure in colonial dress at the bedside, as if taking a pulse. The story is not in the inn's own history.
"While her name remains unknown to this day, the lady of the house still makes her presence known. Residents across the Bay, those traveling by boat and pedestrians on foot have reported a light shining"Casablanca Inn on the Bay
The building
Before you book
| Room to request | Room 8 (Tour lore links Margaret Hantelman's ghost to room 8), Room 10 (Tour lore places a Spanish doctor's bedside visits here), Room 12 (Tour lore places a Spanish doctor's bedside visits here) |
|---|---|
| Does the hotel tell the stories? | ✓ Yes The inn's own website has a page telling the Lady with the Lantern ghost story |
| Built | 1914, as hotel (Matanzas Hotel), later a boarding house |
| Historic listing | None found |
| Historic Hotels of America | No |
| Google rating | 4.1 from 683 reviews |
| Address | 24 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine, FL 32084 |
| The Castillo de San Marcos | 0.2 mi (0.3 km), 5 min walk |
Sources
7 independent sources, quotes checked
- Casablanca Inn on the BayThe hotel
- Ghosts & Gravestones (Historic Tours of America)Ghost tour
- US Ghost AdventuresGhost tour
- Ghost City ToursGhost tour
- Haunted Rooms, 2026Blog
- Ghost Haunts, 2023Blog
- Florida Trippers, 2021Blog
Photo: The Castillo de San Marcos in St. Augustine, Daniel Schwen, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons. This is the area, not the hotel.
Around the Casablanca Inn
Straight-line distances from the front door; walking times allow for streets. Places from OpenStreetMap.
Eat and drink
- Harbor View Café1 min walk
- Aviles Restaurant & Lounge1 min walk
- Crucial Coffee Cafe2 min walk
- The Gourmet Hut2 min walk
- Café del Hidalgo2 min walk
- Sangrias2 min walk
See nearby
- Grace Gallery1 min walk
- Cutter & Cutter Fine Art4 min walk
- Rodriguez House4 min walk
- Colonial Quarter4 min walk
- Saint Augustine Pirate & Treasure Museum4 min walk
- Phillip Anthony Signature Gallery5 min walk
Other haunted hotels
- Casa Monica6 min walk
- Casa de Sueños6 min walk
- Kenwood Inn8 min walk
- Bayfront Marin House9 min walk
Cemeteries
- Trinity Episcopal Parish Memorial Garden5 min walk
- Tolomato Cemetery7 min walk
- Huguenot Cemetery7 min walk
- Otto Curtis Lightner Gravesite7 min walk
Questions
Is the Casablanca Inn haunted?
The inn tells its own ghost story: the Lady with the Lantern, a Prohibition-era widow owner. Residents, boaters and guests report a light on the roof on moonless nights, plus footsteps and a misty figure inside.
Which rooms at the Casablanca Inn are said to be haunted?
Ghost City Tours names rooms 8, 10 and 12. These stories come from tour lore and are not part of the inn's own history; Haunted Rooms could not confirm them.
Can children stay at the Casablanca Inn?
No. The inn is adults only; Haunted Rooms says guests must be 21 or over.
